Island Fresh Café
Market rank
#1 / 2
Island Fresh Café is a popular cafe located in the heart of Paia, Maui, Hawaii. They offer a variety of breakfast and lunch options featuring fresh, local ingredients and Hawaiian-inspired dishes.
Health scoreMay 24, 2026
92
out of 100
#1
Market rank
4.6
Avg rating
1,209
Total reviews
No public response signal
Response rate
Unknown
Years active
92
Health score
Health score · 92 / 100
Six signals, weighted continuously.
Operator computes a Health score continuously. It is the one number that tells you if this shop is winning, losing, or steady. Here is how Island Fresh Café broke down on May 24, 2026.
Score trend
30d90d1y
Island Fresh Café
90 days trailing
Market position
#1 of 2 Cafe in Paia.
Operator ranks every cafe in Paia continuously using reviews, response rate, and local market share.
#1
of 2 Cafe businesses
in Paia
in Paia
Leaderboard refreshes continuously. Your rank updates the moment signal lands.
Cafe · Paia
Top 5 shown
1
Island Fresh Café · this page
1,209
2
Story Maui
168
See full Cafe Paia leaderboardRecent activity
What changed this month.
Holding a top 1 slot in Paia Cafe
Market leaderboard refreshed this morning
In person
The shop, the team, the work.
The numbers tell one story. The photos tell another. Images are indexed from Google Business Profile, the public website, and connected social profiles.
Reviews · 1,209 total
What customers say.
Reviews pulled continuously from Google, Yelp, and Meta. Aggregate weighted by recency and source authority.
4.6★★★★★1,209 reviews
5 ★
624
4 ★
312
3 ★
156
2 ★
78
1 ★
39
Review themes refresh continuously. Check back once Operator has synthesized enough comments from Island Fresh Café’s reviews.
About & contact
Where to find them.
About
Island Fresh Café is a popular local cafe in Paia, Maui, offering fresh, Hawaiian-inspired dishes with strong customer ratings. It caters to both locals and visitors looking for quality coffee and pastries.
Phone
Email
Website
Booking
Hours
Price range
moderate
Specialties
Competitors · top 5
Side by side with the neighborhood.
The cafe shops Island Fresh Cafécompetes with most often, ranked by Operator’s health score. Tap any row for that shop’s full page.
#
Business
Rating
Reviews
Response
Score
1
Island Fresh Café
★4.6
1,209
No response signal
92
2
Story Maui
★4.8
168
No response signal
81
FAQ
Quick answers.
The questions people ask before they call.
Contact Island Fresh Café
Call (808) 495-3133 for service. The website islandfreshmaui.com also has direct contact info.
Hours for Island Fresh Café
Hours are listed on this page under About and contact. Operator refreshes them continuously from public sources.
Services offered by Island Fresh Café
Island Fresh Café offers Espresso Drinks, Cold Brew, Pastries, Specialty Coffee, Catering, Private Events. Operator refreshes service lists continuously from public sources.
Licensing and insurance
License and insurance details have not been verified with Island Fresh Café yet. Find the listing to add them.
Estimates and availability
Estimate and availability details are refreshing. Call ahead for the fastest confirmation.
Health score formula
Six weighted components: Reviews and rating (25%), Response rate (15%), Market rank (20%), Financial health (20%), Jobs flow (10%), and Operator activity (10%). Recomputed continuously using data from Google, Yelp, Meta, and direct integrations.
Local rank in Paia
Free
Add Island Fresh Café to your account
Activate the Market Analyst for free. Health Score, ranking, and competitor signal refreshed every night, no card required.
- ✓Market Analyst, free forever. Health Score, market rank, and competitor moves.
- ✓No card, no contract. Activate in two minutes.
- ✓Upgrade later. Add the full team only when the math makes sense.