Pick Auto Repair in Indianapolis and get rank changes, new openings, and competitor moves every Monday.
Hortons Garage Indy, LLC is a top-rated auto repair shop serving Indianapolis, IN. With 230 reviews and a 4.9-star rating, they have built a strong reputation in the community.
Data updated Apr 11, 2026
| # | Business | Rating | Reviews | Response |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Keep Swingin Garage | 5.0 | 273 | Tracking |
| #2 | Carmel Auto Repair | 5.0 | 178 | Tracking |
| #3 | Martin Automotive LLC | 5.0 | 155 | Tracking |
| #4 | Khalid’s Auto Care | 5.0 | 25 | Tracking |
| #5 | THE AUTO CENTER | 4.9 | 627 | Tracking |
| #6 | Hortons Garage Indy, LLC | 4.9 | 230 | Tracking |
| #7 | American Auto Repair | 4.9 | 223 | Tracking |
| #8 | Dave´s Mechanic Shop (DMS) | 4.9 | 183 | Tracking |
| #9 | South Indy Auto Repair | 4.9 | 54 | Tracking |
| #10 | Euro Motorworks | 4.8 | 897 | Tracking |
| #11 | Malless Auto Service - a Main Street Auto shop | 4.8 | 816 | Tracking |
| #12 | Tyler Automotive | 4.8 | 633 | Tracking |